‘Just Cause’ Eviction Plan of Evanston Raises Legal Issues and Rent Hike Worries

In Evanston, there’s a big discussion about a new rule that could change how landlords and tenants interact.

Alderman Devon Reid from the 8th ward is leading this effort. The idea is to make it harder for landlords to kick out tenants without a good reason. If this rule passes, tenants with year-long leases could stay for a long time, almost like they own the place, unless they break the rules seriously.

This news comes from Evanston Now. It’s part of the city’s plan to protect tenants more.

Kathryn Loan, an assistant city lawyer, says there are some problems with this plan. She says it might not fit well with state laws about how much landlords can raise rent or how freely they can make rental agreements. Also, it might bump into issues about property rights in the Constitution.

Challenges Ahead

There are a lot of things to think about with this new rule. Loan says it might break the state’s rule against controlling rent, especially if landlords can’t raise rent by more than 15 percent.

The proposed rule aims to protect tenants and faces challenges aligning with state laws, sparking nationwide discussion.

Also, making landlords help tenants move out in some situations might make housing costs go up and speed up gentrification. It might also stop small landlords from renting out places.

This isn’t just a local issue. Other places in the country, like New York, are also talking about similar rules. But there, both landlords and tenants don’t agree on what’s best. Some say these rules could make things worse for housing.

Nationwide Debate

Evanston’s situation is part of a bigger talk about tenant rights and making sure people have stable housing.

Assistant city attorney flags potential issues, including conflicts with rent control laws, and housing affordability worries. (Credits: Real Deal)

In New York, for example, people are arguing about whether to have “good cause eviction” rules. Some people worry these rules could mess up housing policies.

This is a big deal for small landlords and unions too. It shows that there’s a tricky balance between keeping tenants safe and making sure landlords can still make money. Small landlords especially are worried about how these rules might affect them.

Looking Forward

Evanston’s plan is ambitious, but it brings up important questions about housing rules and protecting tenants.

A larger conversation emerges on balancing tenant protections with landlord concerns, reflecting national housing policy debates. (Credits: Evanston Now)

While it’s good to stop unfair evictions and help tenants feel more secure, we can’t ignore the legal and money issues that might come up. We can learn from places like New York, where they’ve tried similar things.

As Evanston talks about this rule, they need to think about both the immediate problems and how it might affect the city’s housing market in the long run. It’s important to think about what’s best for everyone involved: landlords, tenants, and the city as a whole.

Sajda Parveen
Sajda Parveen
Sajda Praveen is a market expert. She has over 6 years of experience in the field and she shares her expertise with readers. You can reach out to her at [email protected]
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x